The icon in its little colored square gives the template away.
The Slop Score flags «Icons in a colored square» on 28 of the 63 sloppiest sites in its study and on only 2 of the 167 most careful ones. It almost never shows up on sites someone took care over.
A rounded square in a soft tint, a line icon in the middle, a two-word heading and one sentence. It repeats three, four or six times, usually on the same pale background.
Each card looks clean. What stands out is that the icon says nothing the heading doesn't already say: it is there because the row of benefits looks empty without it.
What the Slop Score looks for
The rule looks for an SVG icon inside a nearly square container, 28 to 80 px a side, with a colored (or gradient) background, corners of at least 6 px, and a heading in the same card. Icons inside buttons, links, the menu and the footer are skipped. Fewer than three and nothing is flagged.
- The more icons like that, the more it weighs: intensity maxes out at nine.
- If any has a gradient, it adds a little more.
- The result's evidence says how many icons it found and which one came first.
On a Tailwind site it is usually a div with rounded-xl, a bg-indigo-500/10 and a Lucide icon inside. The /10 suffix is Tailwind's opacity modifier: the same color at 10 %, which is where the pastel comes from.
What the 509 sites show
In the November study, using the sites people measured in production under the same version of the rules, the signal showed up on 63 of 509. The gap is in who carries it:
- 28 of the 63 sloppiest sites (55 points or more), 44 %.
- 2 of the 167 most careful (15 or less), a little over 1 %.
That is a far wider gap than card grids, which also appear on careful sites. Here what gives it away is not the row but what sits on top of each card. The full numbers are in the study, and the other half of the pattern in identical card grids.
Why the model always adds it
For a generator, the icon is the cheapest way to give each item something visual without having an image. No file to ask for, no weight, and it matches any color. The soft square is what makes a generic icon look designed.
The result is two products with nothing in common showing the same bolt, the same shield and the same rocket. If the icon can be swapped for another site's without anyone noticing, it is not saying anything.
What to use instead
You don't have to remove every icon. Three options, from most to least work:
- A real screenshot of the feature, cropped, in place of the icon. It works best because it shows what the icon only hints at.
- A number or a fact set large above each item: «3 min», «0 plugins». It takes the same space and says something.
- Plain text with hierarchy: a bigger heading, the description in gray and nothing else. A well-written list needs no decoration.
If you keep icons because they help scanning, keep few, without the colored square, and mark them aria-hidden="true": according to MDN, that takes purely decorative content out of the accessibility tree.
Ask your AI tool for it
Review the sections where each item has an icon inside a colored
square. Remove the square and the icon on all but one. In the features
section, use a real product screenshot for the main item. For the
others, set a concrete fact in large type (a number or one word) with
the text below. If any icon remains, no background, from a single
family and with aria-hidden="true". Don't change the copy.Then measure your site with the Slop Score and look for «Icons in a colored square»: it shouldn't appear. If the card rows are flagged too, continue with the prompts guide.
Sources
- background-color, Tailwind CSS (documentación), November 13, 2026
- ARIA: aria-hidden attribute, MDN Web Docs, November 13, 2026
Frequently asked questions
Are icons on a website a bad idea?
No. What the Slop Score flags is the whole pattern: three or more icons in colored squares, each next to a heading, repeated as a row of benefits.
How do I know if my site has icons in colored squares?
Look in the code for containers of about 40 to 60 px with rounded corners and a soft colored background, with an SVG inside. The Slop Score counts them and shows the first one as evidence.